This month’s recipe is from our lead developer Jacob Scott! He’s shared with us his best-in-show apple pie recipe!
“I like to dabble in various hobbies sometimes, and one of those is baking. Part science, part art, 100% edible!
“I started designing this recipe back in 2011 with a fairly simple goal: design an apple pie that was safe against my sister’s lengthy list of food allergies, but also be succulent and avoid the “cardboard” texture you can expect from typical allergen-free foods. Oh, and I wanted to cook it in an iron skillet. I had to get a little creative at first but the pie quickly took on its own unique qualities. I have had several people declare it to be the best apple pie they’ve ever had, with its unique flavor, texture, and just all around melt-in-your-mouth goodness. I also took this pie to an amateur baking competition at a convention in Milwaukee in 2016 and won best in show – with a complement from John de Lancie to boot! You know, that guy who portrayed Q in Star Trek. That guy.”
Jacob’s Apple Pie
Allergens: Soy, Coconut (Optional), Gluten (You can get special flour to avoid that)
Friendly to Allergies: Corn, Milk, Eggs
Prep time: 3.5 hours
Bake time: 1 hour
Serves: about 6 or 8 people
This pie is an exercise in patience, but I promise you it’s worth it in the end. You will need a sharp knife and the wherewithal to use it in such a way to not cut your own fingers. Trust me on this one – you will have a lot of apples to cut. A dull knife is much easier to hurt yourself with while skinning, but that doesn’t mean a sharp knife is safe.
· 2.5 cup flour with about another 1/2 cup for your working surface
· 1 tsp salt
· 1 tsp ginger
· 1 Tbsp sugar (or more, I’ve done up to 2.5)
· 1 cup chilled shortening, cubed
· About 8 Tbsp ice water
· Mix all of the dry ingredients together in a large bowl.
· Mix in the shortening well – you should get the overall consistency of the mix to be akin to small peas.
· Sprinkle in water 1 Tbsp at a time while mixing until you can just form a ball without any noticeably sticky parts. Don’t try to guess this, take it as slow as you need and don’t be afraid to add more flour. Most of the time you won’t need all of the water, so don’t try to use it all.
· Form two patties out of the dough of about the same size, and set aside to chill.
· About 5 lbs of apples. When selecting apples, try to get about 1/2 sweet apples and 1/2 tart apples. In the variation I made for Ciderfest I had equal parts Granny Smith, Golden Delicious, and Braeburn.
· 2/3 cup white sugar
· 1/3 cup white sugar
· about 1/8 cup brown sugar
· 1/4 cup coconut oil OR shortening
· 1/4 tsp cinnamon (don’t go much over this. It’s much too easy to overdo it with cinnamon and you’ll never notice until it’s too late)
· 1/2 tsp fresh-shaved nutmeg OR 1/4 tsp ground nutmeg
(Nothing quite like freshly shaved nutmeg – if you’re careful you can save the nuts to use over and over, too)
· Peel and then slice all of the apples one by one into the skillet until the apples just crest the edges. You want the slices to be about 1/2 x 1/4 inch, but don’t make them all identical – some larger and some smaller is good. I’d recommend alternating sweet/tart apples to make sure you end up with an even consistency. I also recommend setting aside a bowl to keep the skins in so you can keep your workplace tidy.
· Sprinkle the 1/3 cup of sugar into the apples, then cover and let simmer on a stove on low heat for about ten minutes.
· Remove from heat, and scoop out the apples from the skillet into a separate bowl. Save this for later. Save the apple juice in the skillet!
· Turn the stove back on to low heat and add the 2/3 cup of sugar. You may have to add parts of the sugar as the sugar caramelizes instead of all at once. Stir constantly to keep the sugar from burning to the skillet, and remove from heat once all of the sugar is caramelized.
· Pour the caramel into the apples and lightly toss the apples with the cinnamon and nutmeg.
· Carefully rub brown sugar into the skillet to absorb any residue caramel and coat the skillet in brown sugar caramel. Set aside to cool a little (It’s ok to be warm, but ideally shouldn’t be too hot to touch for when we add the crust)
Now we make the crust. The bottom part goes in fairly easy once rolled out as the shortening in the crust is pretty forgiving. Roll out one of the crust halves until it is wider than the skillet plus double the wall height – you want the crust to fill all of the skillet so that the apples can’t get out of the crust while baking. Make sure to flip the crust routinely while rolling and make sure there’s always a thin dusting of flour under it. I normally also use the rolling pin to transfer the crust from the working surface to the skillet – just carefully roll the crust onto the pin, then unroll it onto the pan and gently mold and press it to the edges. If you crack the crust, gently rub the surface while pressing the edges together to get a seal – don’t press hard or you’ll make it too thin. Once the crust is in the skillet, use a knife to trim off any bits that stick over the top.
Now add the pie filling! Now is also a good time to start the oven preheat, as it should be up to temp by the time we’re done with the top crust. Preheat the oven to 380F.
The top is quite a bit harder to do if you do it with a lattice like what I have shown, but I’ll give you a little secret: Start with the middle pieces, use a rolling pin whenever possible for bending back bits to work on, and if things break, they’re fine and you can re-mold them without re-rolling them. Also, broken strips aren’t noticeable if the break is under another strip.
Sprinkle with a little bit of white sugar, and bake at 380F for an hour. The crust should change to a light golden color.
And that’s it! Make sure to let it cool for at least an hour before serving, although it’s probably best after about two hours. If you want to cook it later, the pie can be refrigerated without issue for two days or frozen for six months (although it won’t taste as good after freezing it). If you freeze it, add about 30 minutes to the bake time. After baking, the pie will keep pretty well for about a week if kept covered and refrigerated, or about ten minutes if left uncovered on my kitchen table. *poof* gone.
Seriously, transcribing my notes into a blog made me hungry for pie.
Featured in the Facet Newsletter for July of 2020.